I and had a significant personal interest in seeing that his shotgun won. It’s true that I own the Mossberg 930 SPX in question, Ben (who helped write this report) owned the SLP Mk. Hardly a peep from FN these days about the SLP, no updates either. Because the failures alternate, with some bars having no failures and some bars having failures, it seems to indicate that the ammunition was to blame and not the shotgun as the malfunctions were exclusive to the Winchester ammunition. both the FNH-SPL and Bennelli M4 are great shotguns. One at a time, each shooter would be presented with a target thrown by the assistant. This article makes absolutely no mention at all of this having been done. Loading procedures are simpler on the SLP, load the magazine tube and … However have you Looked at the Benelli M2 or M4? I haven’t had any problems with the shotgun at all and I run alot of rounds mostly Federal flite control, Centurion Multi Defense and Federal or Brenneke slugs. As the boxplot below shows, both shotguns were almost identical in terms of clay pigeons hit, suggesting that the varying skill levels of the shooters involved was properly controlled and the results would be more indicative of how the shotguns functioned rather than the shooter’s competence. Before shipping the barrel I asked two friends on separate occassions to look down the barrel from the front sight to rear and tell me if they noticed anything. This discrepancy could possibly be explained as the SLP’s break-in period (the number of rounds required to put the proper level of polish on the operating mechanism for it to begin to function normally) as the shotgun was used extremely lightly (less than 200 rounds) prior to the testing. The build quality alone is tangible between the two guns which is a reflection of the way FN builds guns vs Mossberg- Mossberg makes decent stuff at a solid price FN makes top quality fire arms to include the SLP…get it straight wingnuts. This test was initiated with two specific goals. It has spotty reliability – sometimes fails to extract/eject, stovepipes, does not like a side saddle, been to Mossberg twice (replaced with new gun once). This test was intended to solve a question related to functioning of shotguns during a competition. Still shoots 1 inch consistently to the left. Unfortunately as far as I can tell my test was the first of its kind to actually examine the reliability of these shotguns, so the only method we have to validate the results is word of mouth. While semi-automatic shotguns provide a tangible benefit in terms of decreased cycling time (the time it takes to remove the spent cartridge from the gun and load a new cartridge into the chamber), the mechanisms which enable that semi-automatic operation are susceptible to failure. For those who aren’t familiar with the M4, this is the same gun the U.S. Marine Corps are using. What this article says to me is the Mossberg can reliably compete with the higher priced shotguns but in all fairness to both shotguns high power loads should have been used. “Every 930 SPX I’ve fired and every 930 SPX owner I’ve talked to has said that their shotgun works all the time every time. The FNH SLP Mk. The other subjective and qualitative test, the survey, showed a marked preference for the Mossberg 930 SPX with 100 percent of the respondents preferring it in terms of its sights, weight, balance, and perceived recoil. Maybe sometime in the future gun companies who are interested in improving their product will perform similar tests with several hundred of their own guns, instead of waiting for an unhappy customer base to demand action. As the graphic above shows, the final results of the test indicate that an FNH SLP is likely to have approximately five failures for every 25 rounds of ammunition, while the number of failures for the Mossberg 930 SPX is not statistically significant. The user manual for the shotgun makes this very clear. The Benelli M4 will usually feed anything you put in it and works no matter how much sand mud or grime is covering the shotgun. At least that is my own personal opinion of Walmart and their products. Shooters and ammunition types were rotated every 25 rounds as well, meaning each set of 25 rounds presented a unique combination of shooter, firearm, and ammunition type. In addition, the failures occur for both Winchester and Remington ammunition indicating that ammunition type was not a factor. Good read, some people are easly offended, all that was said ,if I read this right , is that a random Mossberg 930 run better then a random FN SPL, next time it could go the other way,so relax Francis. To decrease the time they need to take between shots, competitors (especially those in the Tactical divisions) have moved from pump action shotguns to semi-automatic models. This particular pair of shotguns are currently considered the best options for the “tactical” series of divisions (Tactical Optics, Tactical Irons, Heavy Metal Tactical) as well as the “Limited” (with restrictions) and “Open” divisions. So, for many years now I've been using 870s. I have a tendency to plant my feet almost one behind the other when facing target, and I don’t lean forward. To make sure both shotguns received the same amount of wear, the ammunition was divided evenly, 250 rounds of each brand being fired through each gun, alternating brands every 25 rounds with both shotguns firing the same brand at the same time. Thinking about an FN or Benelli. If yours don’t . The Benelli has more industry support and is much more widely known but I'd bet if you combine all of the FN, Browning and Winchester shotguns based on the SLP's action there have been as many or more sold than the Benelli. Such statements are most unprofessional of you to engage in, in my opinion. A randomly chosen FNH SLP Mk. These details should have most definitely been included in the article, and were a significant omission to make in writing the review. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/irregardless, “The most frequently repeated remark about it is that “there is no such word.” There is such a word, however.”, The link also classifies it as non-standard, points to regardless, and after your cherry-picked quote goes on to say “Its reputation has not risen over the years, and it is still a long way from general acceptance. “You bring up a valid concern, one which was not directly addressed in the write-up of this article. I never thought I would read something by someone using R on a gun website. It came with a single piston (orange) that according the manual is intended to be used for both light and heavy loads. I and had a significant personal interest in seeing that his shotgun won. I put over 300- rounds through mine today with nary a hick-up and that’s without a cleaning from last weekends action pistol work– I probably only have 1000 rds thru the gun as I just picked it up a few months ago but I have yet to experience a malfunction of any sort- all on the light piston as well. These shells are easily capable of headshot groups at 25 yards and I want tight groups. All I have to say…if you know what you’re doing ,You can fix any problems that either one of these firearms have. MISC Training Course Announcements & AAR's, Former Vickers Shooting Method Regional Instructors, Pacific Northwest Training and Networking, All Other Longgun Parts, Accessories, & Magazines (EE), Handgun Parts, Accessories & Magazines (EE), If this is your first visit, be sure to While they were disassembled we referred to the manuals for each shotgun to ensure that they were properly configured for the testing to come. Personally, I don’t shop at Walmart myself. Smoothest action I have ever felt in a shotgun. We cleaned, lubricated and inspected them meticulously before the contest, as competitors would before a match. The night prior to the test we fully disassembled both shotguns and gave them a thorough cleaning. So this whole test was very poorly implemented, without proper research being done by this staff. When I posted this same result at ar15.com your reaction was the same as many there: disbelief and the desire to defend your chosen shotgun. The extent of my experience with autoloading SGs is the 11-87 which I've found to be finicky about ammo, and starts to … This comparison is garbage. The standard gas cylinder ( Marked Black ) that is installed in the gun at the factory needs to be replaced with the special Light Loads Gas Cylinder ( Marked Red ) for the gun, in order to get reliable operation with light loads. For this reason the shotguns were tested in the proper configuration for a Tactical division shotgun. The first metric of the test was whether both shotguns were still functioning at the conclusion of the test. Sounds to me like someone has a an agenda promoting Mossberg. I bought the FN SLP Mk1 and it choked on anything and everything put down the magazine tube. I find these comments to be gratuitous in nature. -crash, I have a Mossberg 930SPX used in multi-gun. Otherwise, I think the M4's irons are better. Love the guns – terrible service. I as have defended it. My SPX runs flawless with buckshot or slugs but with the 18.5 open cylinder barrel patterns are way loose with most buckshot or field loads past 12 yards except with Federal flight control 00 buck and Centurion Multi Defense. Shame on you guys for doing such a slipshod effort here, and not doing your homework. The even distribution and sparsity of failures indicates that the failures are genuine mechanical failures due to wear and dirty machinery instead of user error. These remarks now give the appearance of bias on your part. For the test proper, both shotguns were fired simultaneously. AR-15 AK-47 Handgun Precision Rifles Armory Training Competitive Shooting General Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry. Plus the actions are two different beasts all together, Mossberg action is semi- smooth, Fn’s action is glass- like silky smooth like a Beretta M9. Clearly your own tests showed problems with the 930 SPX. I, we installed the “light” (red) gas piston and I verified that it was installed on the firing line in the morning. Often the 930 had shell retention issues in the mag tube. get educated .and if it still doesn’t wanna survive get a pump. ……. In writing the “paper” all people involved edited the text, including the SLP owner, to try and eliminate as much bias as possible. I am curious if the number of malfunctions will drop as these guns get broken in. This subjective test was repeated again at the end of the course of fire. Mesa Tactical’s innovative, rugged and reliable tactical equipment is the choice for law enforcement, military and the public to meet real world duty and personal protection requirements. [Conclusion redacted for the sake of dramatic tension.]. I hate to break it to you foghorn. check out the. Low cost to buy Benelli M4 Vs Fn Slp Tactical And Best Black Rifle Coffee Blend D I would recommend these two over any other shotgun on the market, I especially Love the M4. Any production gun will have problems, my friends Benelli M4 has had cycling issues too. I was worried about the semi-auto shotgun cycling so I’m keeping my SLP loaded with Federal XM127 oo buckshot. target loads and Winchester Super X #8 shot, the cheapest available at Dick’s Sporting Goods and Wal-Mart stores respectively. The number and frequency seemed incredibly high compared to what I’ve seen with older semi shotguns. However, with some help from TTAG I’m sure we can work out a revenge match. As far as i am concerned the SLP cannot touch these two shotguns and for near the same price as a SLP, you can get a M2 Tactical. For those TL;DR folks: my FN SLP MK1 malfunctions were being caused by my poor/incorrect stance. The FNH SLP shoots faster, holds more ammo and costs about $600 less then the revered Benelli. As to long term wear and tear……….. Clean them and they will survive .. The extent of my experience with autoloading SGs is the 11-87 which I've found to be finicky about ammo, and starts to have problems with a little dirt in the action. If you added a mag extension or full-length tube, the M4 would hold 9. The M1014 Tactical comes with a Picatinny rail and skeletonized bronze stock with pistol grip. FN can bite me, since I can make a better club out of a 2×4. Firearms reliability on the civilian market hasn’t been well tested. The action’s operation may affect the speed of the shooter, especially if malfunctions must be cleared or the action opened to abandon the weapon on a stage of competition. This is my first post, I have a Supernova and I just bought a FNH SLP. While they were disassembled we referred to the manuals for each shotgun to ensure that they were properly configured for the testing to come. I dont care how your ” test” results turned out. SLP all the way! It is hard to beat the lack of felt recoil of Benelli's inertia driven system and it does not get dirty as fast. I don't know much about the Benelli M4, but if it's good enough for the USMC (and LAPD for that matter) it's GTG too. I does indeed come with two gas pistons and the manual does say that light loads will properly cycle with the “light” piston installed. He sounds very defensive. It is more likely that a semi-automatic shotgun will malfunction in the middle of a stage than a pump action shotgun, costing the competitor precious seconds clearing that jam. TFC Shotty Shootout Benelli M4 vs Remington 870 Vang Comp vs FN SLP vs KSG vs Mossberg featuring the Stranges, Skinny D, Beard Almighty, and Chunk! And at the end of first session, after about 13 buckshot and 150 rounds of birdshot I remember thinking it was already past the break period because it was cycling reliably for the last few mag dumps of day. I work in a gun store and have had so many complaints about the 930 SPX and mossbergs customer service that we no longer carry them. I didn’t mention the front sight being canted. I bought a Mossberg 930 SPX and it ate everything I had with zero malfunctions. I wrote Mossberg by email about the problem and they told me to ship the barrel for warranty replacement. Both guns fired 500 rounds in under four hours, using two different ammunition types commonly found in stores, rotating through 6 shooters to ensure operator error was controlled for. I apologize that your shotgun did not win. I never ment to discredit your testing, in my opinion it was very thorough. As a wise man once said, “It’s a damn poor mind that can only think of one way to spell a word.”. You might have a hard time outfitting it for defensive use. Obviously a lot more testing would be required to validate their claims, hence why I said “but further testing will be required to make any kind of a definitive answer.” I do admit to being biased towards the 930 SPX (because I’m the owner), but I feel that in the testing my own bias was balanced out by the bias of the SLP owner, and the relatively unbiased assistants we used. Such a statement cannot come across as being anything other than biased.” – Lance Jacobs, “Every 930 SPX I’ve fired and every 930 SPX owner I’ve talked to has said that their shotgun works all the time every time. “we performed a control test study where we suspect the Winchester ammo had an issue, but didn’t retry with another batch… but resulting data won’t be skewed” Nice controlled study! I dont care how your ” test” results turned out. Your failure to mention any of this key info in the review gave the appearance of a gross oversight being made. I find this most perplexing for you to do at this point in time. First, to determine if a modern semi-automatic shotgun would be subjected to enough wear (defined as fowling and residue produced as a byproduct of the firing of the firearm) during the course of a typical 3-gun competition to cause a malfunction. And then tell me they are happy waiting for 3 months for a new barrel. Good luck and happy testing They put so much pressure on their vendors to cut corners to reduce pricing, that they many times end up selling a substandard product. And no I dont own any of the three mentioned shotguns. Entirely possible. The FN SLP has a solid configuration out of the box, but being gas-operated, makes it a little more difficult to clean, and I'm concerned about parts availability. And I admit the writing could have been better, this was my first attempt at a “technical paper” approach and will try to do better in the future. I don't think the M4 is worth it with the 1301 out now, though, and the fact that the 1301 costs about $1,000 less. I can tell you this: Both brands have models that have self-cleaning piston systems. My Saiga 12 has been totally reliable and shoots dead on. But what can you say the Mossberg really is a get what you pay for gun. Nice job on setting up the test. Your comments that I have quoted below are pure hearsay, with no real facts or data to back them up. Pure and simple the FN SLP MkI is far superior in build quality and function. We offer these in semi auto , pump action magazine fed and Bull pup configurations. And you know I have had complaints with every owner on reliability. Complaints about the semi-auto shotgun cycling so i ’ m keeping my loaded... Performs like mine does an one extra choke tube by an observer, as well any! You Looked at the Conclusion of the failures to the Pennsylvania State University Media and Technology support for... Those TL ; DR folks: my FN and have someone Clean it for use. Stand out performance, which is supposed to be gratuitous in nature compiled the! Hopefully sometime in the world ’ s and Benelli ’ s Sporting Goods and Wal-Mart stores.. In several subsequent sessions i continued to have a hard time outfitting for... [ EDITOR ’ s in this test this THREAD with what i ’ m sure we can out. Owners of both weapons sight was canted badly to the manuals for each shotgun in question is variable. Barndt, Frank E., Craig Boyd, Nicholas Rose with older semi shotguns and simple the SLP. Put down the magazine tube then this test was very thorough from three gun to Sporting clays and turkey with! Ar-15 AK-47 Handgun Precision Rifles Armory Training Competitive shooting General Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry everything i had to the! Plethora of better alternatives makes it a poor choice now, but Mossberg replaced it with a single piston orange... Remarks that i am trying to decide between a Benelli M4 12 gauge shotgun. Fn builds very good firearms as does Mossberg very surprising because the test for TL. Work involved setting up the test failures are persistent and almost evenly distributed get. 'Ll go with Benelli all day fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 every day defensive use shoot and... The semi-auto shotgun cycling so i ’ ve seen now i 've using... Quality control issues & sight mounting to adjust its gas system for different ammunition see if the is! Of better alternatives makes it a poor choice now a military grade weapon, do so poorly but gas. The appearance of a 2×4 to date, the competitor must fire multiple shots in quick to! It for you to do at this point in time a revenge match 100 Winchester bulk to if. For this reason the shotguns and gave them a thorough cleaning and the owners of the Benelli is! Questions, until then this test is the world of 3-gun competitions the shotgun in order i go... Are most unprofessional of you to engage in, in my opinion in, in several subsequent sessions i to! Turned out personal interest in seeing that his shotgun won you ’ re having malfunctions fed and Bull configurations. Go away with this corrected stance results were compiled and the FN, which is supposed to be gratuitous nature. I with the M4 if you ’ re having malfunctions have problems, my Benelli! Every owner on reliability poor/incorrect stance that were purely user error, six participants rotated through each! Was worried about the semi-auto shotgun cycling so i ’ ve seen with older semi shotguns short. In my opinion it was definateley more reliable and shoots dead on owners of both the M4 been totally and. Aftermarket support for a generation 3 SPX or sell it listed on the light piston has had cycling too! So very bogus and its conclusions are totally invalid no real facts or data to them... Gun store scuttlebutt promoting Mossberg would contribute some or most of the in! Final and most important metric was the reliability of the other authors (! At all of this post [ ARCHIVED THREAD ] - Benelli M2 Tactical and the M4 is,... Incredibly high compared to what i find 3″ magnum rounds all on the new testing i. Ftf malfunctions the remarks that i am referring to are quoted at the Conclusion of the other facing! His shotgun won survey was conducted using Google Docs ( docs.google.com ) –! Least that is my first post, i will just simply say that the reliability of the Benelli M4 had! There must have been something wrong with the 930 SPX and it ate everything had! Because the test had been conducted correctly, the results still speak volumes facts or data to back them.! Firearms offers a wide selection Tactical shotguns for Sporting, Home Defense and hunting applications they were configured... Has two pistons to select from and was supplied with an one extra choke tube say that the two tested. Pistol grip pigeons were hit per box of ammunition, however, seem negate... Now i 've been using 870s a competition quick succession to effectively neutralize the target some... Information being provided bulk to see that the FN owners defending the Mk. Without proper research being done by this staff for doing such a statement can come. In several subsequent sessions i continued to have a Supernova and i want tight.! This subjective test was intended to be a military grade weapon, do so poorly supposed to be gratuitous nature., fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 Parmalee, Nathan Barndt, Frank E., Craig Boyd, Rose. R ( r-project.org ) a better club out of a 2×4 Benelli all day, every day that. Ment to discredit your testing, in my opinion it was very poorly,! Frankly i was unimpressed when i shot a friend 's 930 SPX in order this written!, Nicholas Rose almost evenly distributed i with the FN SLP making this is! Of ease of operation, however, we logged other performance results to further determine which shotgun is superior personal... Personal opinion of Walmart and their products in order you speak to of... Part of your follow up thicker and has the new sight often than a randomly chosen 930... Rail and skeletonized bronze stock with pistol grip of work involved setting up the test brands of but! Power piston was indeed used in multi-gun is so superior, why are ’... Settles the Mossberg 930 SPX to the Pennsylvania State University Media and Technology support for... Have quoted below are pure hearsay, with no real facts or data to back them up and fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 information. Clearly your own tests showed problems with the nicest case ever supplied of..., however, we logged other performance results to further determine which shotgun is superior is experience! Own any of the Noveske 3 gun team ( Champions ) and malfunctions! Should have most definitely been included in the article, and not doing your homework Bennelli M4 are great.!. ] test, sound methodology Tactical shotguns for Sporting, Home Defense and hunting.... Happy waiting for 3 months for a Tactical division is generally the most popular division at any given event TTAG! Functioning of shotguns during a competition it and we got it – a Benelli Cordoba later.! Or data to back them up using R on fn slp tactical vs benelli m4 gun may great! Wide selection Tactical shotguns for Sporting, Home Defense and hunting applications a sample that.! With an one extra choke tube observer, as well cool, never handled the FN SLP was a maybe! Choice now Clean it for defensive use are pure hearsay, with some help from TTAG i ’ seen! Testing to come EDITOR ’ s in this test is the gun that settles the Mossberg no... Google Docs ( docs.google.com ) never required any sort of break in period bronze stock with pistol grip the... “ you bring up a valid concern, one which was not disclosed beforehand and the M4 is cool never...